A key integral in the deri¨ation of the size-dependent ( ) Maxwell᎐Garnett MG formula presented in the subject paper is not only noncon¨ergent, but also unnecessary. The correct deri¨ation of the MG formula, based on the so-called Fikioris approach, has been a¨ailable for se¨eral years.
Comparison of long-wavelength T-matrix multiple-scattering theory and size-dependent Maxwell–Garnett formula
✍ Scribed by C. P. Neo; V. K. Varadan; V. V. Varadan
- Publisher
- John Wiley and Sons
- Year
- 1999
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 111 KB
- Volume
- 23
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0895-2477
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
✦ Synopsis
Wa¨e attenuation in a dielectric-in-dielectric composite is calculated using the long-wa¨elength T-matrix multiple-scattering theory and the size-dependent Maxwell᎐Garnett formula. Results obtained are first compared, and then followed by their comparisons with the experimental results and other theoretical results. An interesting obser¨ation made is that the size-dependent Maxwell᎐Garnett formula predicts monotonically increasing wa¨e attenuation with increasing concentration of inclusions, whereas the computed results from the multiple-scattering theory and other formulas, together with the experimental results, indicate maximum wa¨e attenuation at a certain concentration of inclusions. It is shown that the size-dependent Maxwell᎐Garnett formula gi¨es good prediction of wa¨e attenuation only up to inclusion concentration of about 2%, and the T-matrix multiple-scattering theory in the long-wa¨elength approximation gi¨es good prediction of wa¨e attenuation e¨en beyond the inclusion concentration of 2%.
📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES