✍ Scribed by Roger Lass
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
Roger Lass is concerned about the nature of argumentation within linguistics and the status of its data and theoretical constructs. Through an examination of standard strategies of explanation in historical linguistics (particularly of phonological change), in the light of past approaches to scientific epistemology, Dr Lass convincingly demonstrates that attempts to model explanations of linguistic change on those of the physical sciences are failures both in practice and in principle. Linguists can neither assimilate their discipline crudely to the natural or the other human sciences nor, at the other extreme, shelter behind the notion of a private self-validating paradigm. Although Dr Lass outlines some tentative paths towards an alternative epistemology, his main concern is that linguists should confront the philosophical implications of their subject, and he raises questions which both linguists and philosophers will need to consider.
📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES
本书系统地提出了一种不同于乔姆斯基观点的语言演变理论，把生物学和语言学的一些不同的立场整合在一起，旨在实践一种综合功能主义的主张。书中不仅大量吸收了社会语言学的理论和方法，而且吸收了功能一类型学派的语言演变理论的思路，并将这些理论较好地整合在以广义选择理论为基础的语句选择理论之中。 本书具有强烈的理论意识与熟练的理论建构套路，与国内汉语历史语言学研究的朴实风格形成了鲜明的对比，可以为汉语的历时研究提供一个可供借鉴的理论模型
William Croft's text weaves together recent research findings from sociolinguistics, historical linguistics, grammatical change, pragmatics, social variation, language contact and genetic linguistics.
This collection of articles offers insights into language change as a function of communicative use. The multiple factors underlying change are described and possible explanations are adduced. It is shown that change is a function of communicative choices and their mapping onto the rule system, a ma
In Explaining Explanation, David-Hillel Ruben provides a non-technical discussion of some of the main historical attempts to explain the concept of explanation, examining the works of Plato, Aristotle, John Stuart Mill, and Carl Hempel. Building on and developing the insights of these historical fig
I. Getting our bearings -- II. Plato on explanation -- III. Aristotle on explanation -- IV. Mill and Hempel on explanation -- V. The ontology of explanation -- VI. Arguments, laws, and explanation -- VII. A realist theory of explanation.