๐”– Scriptorium
โœฆ   LIBER   โœฆ

๐Ÿ“

Nagarjuna's Madhyamaka: A Philosophical Introduction

โœ Scribed by Jan Westerhoff


Publisher
Oxford University Press, USA
Year
2009
Tongue
English
Leaves
257
Category
Library

โฌ‡  Acquire This Volume

No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.

โœฆ Synopsis


As the title-page of Professor Westerhoff's "Nagarjuna's Madhyamaka: A Philosophical Introduction" clearly implies, it is an examination not directly of Buddhist meditation or other religious practices, but an exploration of various Western approaches to their underlying philosophy in the thought of Mahayana's leading philosopher, Nagarjuna (ca. 150 - 250 c.e)., especially as revealed in his "Fundamental Verses of the Middle Way" (Mulamadhyamakakarika). He is the principal philosopher shared by the "Northern" (Mahayana) schools of Buddhism -- that is, China, Korea, Japan, Tibet, Central Asia, and most of SE Asia.

Westerhoff cites Andrew Tuck (1990) as dividing the history of Western interest in this area of Buddhist thought into three parts: (1) The phase of Theodore Stcherbatsky's "The Conception of Buddhist Nirvana" (1927), and T.R.V. Murti, "The Central Philosophy of Buddhism: A Study of the Madhyamika System" (1955) -- the "Kantian phase"; (2) the "analytic phase," beginning with Richard Robinson's 1957 article, "Some Logical Aspects of Nagarjuna's System," and (3) a "post-Wittgensteinian phase" of interpreting Nagarjuna via Frederick Streng's "Emptiness" and Chris Gudmunsen's "Wittgenstein and Buddhism" -- "the new key term of the post-Wittgensteinian phase was pratityasamutpada," or "dependent origination."

Now . . . "it has become evident that Nagarjuna is worthy of philosophical investigation in his own right. There is no need to legitimate a study by setting out to show him to be a proto-Kant, proto-Wittgenstein, or proto-Derrida." (12)

The 242 pages (including index) of Westerhoff's survey are not easy reading, although the author makes every effort to organize his material and argue his points as lucidly as one could expect. For example, Contents: Abbreviations; 1. Introduction (5 items on Nagarjuna, pp3-18); 2. Svabhava (2 items); 3. Role of Negation in Nagarjuna's Arguments (3 items); 4. Catuskoti on Tetralemma (4); 5. Causation (5 items); 6. Motion (4 items); 7. The Self (4); 8. Epistemology (4 items); 9. Language (4 items); 10. Conclusion: Narjuna's Philosophical Project (5 items).

The items cite a number of sources in contemporary scholarship, e.g. Jay Garfield's "The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way. Translation and Commentary of Nagarjuna's Mulamadhyamakakarika" Oxford (1995). ISBN-10: 0195093364, ISBN-13:978-0195093360.

Jonardon Ganeri, Professor of Philosophy at the University of Sussex, has written a very positive review of this book in Times Literary Supplement, 11/9/2010: ". . . a book for anyone who thinks that an encounter with another philosophical encounter is worthwhile precisely because of the potentially insettling effect of the encounter on one's own habits of mind. It is, in short, a book for our times."

โœฆ Table of Contents


Contents......Page 10
Abbreviations......Page 12
1. Introduction......Page 18
1.1 Nāgārjuna the Philosopher......Page 19
1.2 Nāgārjunaโ€˜s Works......Page 20
1.3 Methodological Considerations......Page 21
1.4 The Philosophical Study of Nāgārjuna in the West......Page 24
1.5 Overview......Page 27
2. Interpretations of Svabhāva......Page 34
2.1 The Ontological Dimension......Page 35
2.2 The Cognitive Dimension......Page 61
3. The Role of Negation in Nāgārjunaโ€™s Arguments......Page 68
3.1 Nyāya Theory of Negation......Page 69
3.2 Negation and Nondenoting Terms......Page 71
3.3 Negation and Temporal Relations......Page 79
4. The Catuskoti or Tetralemma......Page 82
4.1 Two Kinds of Negation......Page 83
4.2 Rejection of Two Alternatives......Page 85
4.3 Rejection of Four Alternatives......Page 88
4.4 Affirming Four Alternatives: The Positive Tetralemma......Page 104
5. Causation......Page 106
5.1 Causation: Preliminary Remarks......Page 107
5.2 Interdependence of Cause and Effect......Page 109
5.3 The Four Ways of Causal Production......Page 114
5.4 Temporal Relations between Cause and Effect......Page 128
5.5 Analysis of Time......Page 139
6. Motion......Page 144
6.1 Arguments Concerning Motion......Page 145
6.2 The Beginning of Motion......Page 157
6.3 The Interdependence of Mover and Motion......Page 162
6.4 The Second Chapter of the MMK in Its Argumentative Context......Page 165
7. The Self......Page 168
7.1 The Self and Its Parts......Page 169
7.2 The Self and Its Properties......Page 173
7.3 Epistemology of the Self......Page 175
7.4 The Madhyamaka View of the Self......Page 177
8. Epistemology......Page 180
8.1 Means of Knowledge as Self-established......Page 182
8.2 Means of Knowledge and Their Objects as Mutually Established......Page 188
8.3 Temporal Relations between Means and Objects of Knowledge......Page 192
8.4 The Aim of Nāgārjunaโ€™s Arguments......Page 194
9.1 Nāgārjunaโ€™s View of Language and the โ€œNo-Thesisโ€ View......Page 198
9.2 VV 29 in Context......Page 199
9.3 The Semantic Interpretation......Page 203
9.4 The Specific Role of Verse 29......Page 209
10.1 Metaphysics......Page 214
10.2 Personal Identity......Page 223
10.3 Ethics......Page 227
10.4 Epistemology......Page 231
10.5 Language and Truth......Page 234
Bibliography......Page 240
C......Page 254
L......Page 255
S......Page 256
Z......Page 257


๐Ÿ“œ SIMILAR VOLUMES


Nagarjuna's Madhyamaka: A Philosophical
โœ Jan Westerhoff ๐Ÿ“‚ Library ๐Ÿ“… 2009 ๐Ÿ› Oxford University Press, USA ๐ŸŒ English

The Indian philosopher Acharya Nagarjuna (c. 150-250 CE) was the founder of the Madhyamaka (Middle Path) school of Mahayana Buddhism and arguably the most influential Buddhist thinker after Buddha himself. Indeed, in the Tibetan and East Asian traditions, Nagarjuna is often referred to as the 'secon

Nagarjuna's Madhyamaka: A Philosophical
โœ Jan Westerhoff ๐Ÿ“‚ Library ๐Ÿ“… 2009 ๐Ÿ› Oxford University Press ๐ŸŒ English

<span>The Indian philosopher Acharya Nagarjuna (c. 150-250 CE) was the founder of the Madhyamaka (Middle Path) school of Mahayana Buddhism and arguably the most influential Buddhist thinker after Buddha himself. Indeed, in the Tibetan and East Asian traditions, Nagarjuna is often referred to as the

Naฬ„gaฬ„rjuna's Madhyamaka : a philosophic
โœ Nฤgฤrjuna; Westerhoff, Jan; Nฤgฤrjuna, Nagarjuna, Nฤgฤrjuna ๐Ÿ“‚ Library ๐Ÿ“… 2009 ๐Ÿ› Oxford University Press ๐ŸŒ English

The Indian philosopher Acharya Nagarjuna (c. 150-250 CE) was the founder of the Madhyamaka (Middle Path) school of Mahayana Buddhism and arguably the most influential Buddhist thinker after Buddha himself. Indeed, in the Tibetan and East Asian traditions, Nagarjuna is often referred to as the 'secon

Nagarjuna's Philosophy
โœ K. Venkata Ramanan ๐Ÿ“‚ Library ๐Ÿ“… 1987 ๐Ÿ› Motilal Banarsidass ๐ŸŒ English

This work is an exposition of the philosophic conceptions basic to Mahayana Buddhsim as found in the Maha-prajnaparamita-sastra a commentary on the Prajnaparamita-sutras and traditionally attributed to Nagarjuna.

Nagarjuna's Philosophy
โœ K. Venkata Ramanan ๐Ÿ“‚ Library ๐Ÿ“… 1987 ๐Ÿ› Motilal Banarsidass ๐ŸŒ English

This work is an exposition of the philosophic conceptions basic to Mahayana Buddhsim as found in the Maha-prajnaparamita-sastra a commentary on the Prajnaparamita-sutras and traditionally attributed to Nagarjuna. The sastra the earlist and most extensive work in this field is lost in its sanskrit or