Ethics, randomization, and technology assessment
β Scribed by John Lantos
- Publisher
- John Wiley and Sons
- Year
- 1994
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 391 KB
- Volume
- 74
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0008-543X
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
β¦ Synopsis
Randomized controlled trials raise a number of ethical issues. Physicians who participate in such trials must be in a state of "equipoise," or genuine uncertainty about the relative merits of the two arms of the trial. Otherwise, they would be ethically compelled to recommend the treatment they preferred. However, an agreement to participate in a masked trial is an agreement to deny oneself access to the knowledge that might allow one to judge which therapy is better. Physicians may dodge this dilemma in a number of ways. First, they may refuse to participate in randomized control trials. However, this does not allow assumptions about treatment to be tested. Second, they may judge participation ethically acceptable if other clinicians believe that an alternative treatment is h e r . By this formulation, individuals do not need to be in a state of equipoise, as long as the expert medical community is. Finally, they may use alternative methodologies, such a s retrospective studies; crossover studies: or nonmasked, nonrandomized selection of alternative treatments with careful risk stratification and data COIlection. All of these solutions may be valid ways of dealfng with the ethical dilemmas associated with randomm d controlled trials.
π SIMILAR VOLUMES
## Abstract Recent scientific discoveries have made it much easier to test prenatally for various genetic disabilities, such as Down syndrome. However, while many observers have heralded such βadvancesβ for their effectiveness in detecting certain conditions, others have argued that they perpetuate
## Abstract Individuals often differ with respect to their ethical judgments of marketing practices. Personal beliefs are presumably important sources of such differences. This article reports on the development and testing of an original, parsimonious measure of personal moral beliefs based on For
New medical technologies have dramatically changed the range of treatments available to infertile couples (invitro-fertilization, gamete intrafallopian transfer, super ovulation etc) yet the debate continues about what can and should be done in this area. Recent psychological research has focused up