From Publishers Weekly
Distinctly evocative of James Michener's all-encompassing recapitulations of history, this lackluster saga by the author of bestselling London and, most recently, The Forest (2000), is the first of a projected two-volume series billed as the Dublin Saga. Rutherfurd begins his tale of the Emerald Isle in pre-Christian Ireland in A.D. 430 with a tragic romance between a maiden, Dierdre, and a Celtic warrior, Conall, hearkening to the legend of the mythic first-century Celtic hero, Cuchulainn. After Conall is offered up as a sacrifice to the Druid gods, the narrative jumps ahead 20 years to Pat Rick's (St. Patrick's) arrival in Ireland in A.D. 450 and his establishment of a small Christian toehold at Dubh Linn. Five centuries later, the Vikings make their mark, and Rutherfurd skips ahead with chronicles of the monastery at Glendalough, the Book of Kells and the death of Brian Boru (founder of the O'Brians) with his Pyrrhic victory over the high king of Tara in 1014. A retelling of King Henry II's arrival in Ireland in 1171 is followed by a cursory account of the reformation of the Irish Church at the Council of Cashel and the story of an obscure 1370 skirmish at Carrickmines Castle (a minor landmark presently doomed to make room for a highway). Rutherfurd sets the last of his ill-connected and artificial sketches in 1537, with Henry VIII hanging Silken Thomas, and Dublin poised at the dawn of the Renaissance. Readers who persevere will glean plenty of historical detail from these pages, but Rutherfurd's uninspiring storytelling makes the journey a slog.
Copyright Β© Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Historical fiction fans can settle in for a long, cozy read asRutherfurd conducts a spellbinding tour of ancient Ireland. Employingthe chatty style he perfected in his best-selling novels Sarum(1987) and London(1997), he covers 17 centuries of Irishhistory, beginning in pre-Christian Ireland and culminating in themid-sixteenth century. From the passionate tale of Conall andDeirdre--a reworking of the celebrated Cuchulainn legend--to thedesecration of Irish Catholic churches and shrines during the reign ofHenry VIII, the history of this island nation is viewed through akaleidoscope of interwoven historical and fictional characters caughtup in all the pageantry and drama of their particular time and placein history. The real focal point of this sprawling saga is, however,the city of Dublin itself. The first installment in a two-part serieson the origins and evolution of one of the world's most venerableurban centers, the narrative is distinguished by the panoramicportrait it paints of Dublin through the ages. Like James Michener andLeon Uris, Rutherfurd does a magnificent job of packaging a cracklinggood yarn within a digestible overview of complex historicalcircumstances and events. After devouring this initial volume, readerswill eagerly anticipate the publication of the conclusion of thepage-turning Dublin Saga. Margaret Flanagan
Copyright Β© American Library Association. All rights reserved