From Publishers Weekly
While no doubt the bravado with which Hennessy frames his account of daily life in a war zone reveals the crucial but often overlooked heart and mind of a soldier, the unsettling results confirm the vapid promises of war: that in battle, there is no context, no history, but only boredom, adrenaline, or grief. "Fun," "thrill," and "excitement" drive Hennessy, and apparently his comrades as well, even after a lot of blood and death; that this fact endures becomes more horrifying than the wars enveloping them. Hennessy's story jumps from daily life at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst, to drills in the British countryside, to Iraq and Afghanistan, and the sum of these parts never quite adds up to a cohesive tale, though sections share a hurried disjointedness that occasionally comes off as narrative momentum. The jargon and relentless use of acronyms certainly captures military speech but obscures the basic development of many scenes. Though a glossary of terms is included, flipping for every DTDF, OPTAG NCO, and GPMG would make for more back-and-forth than any attention span would permit.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Starred Review Oxford graduate Hennessey decided he wanted to do something exciting, so he went to Sandhurst, Englandโs Royal Military Academy, and then to Bosnia, Iraq, and, ultimately, Afghanistan as a lieutenant and platoon leader in the Grenadier Guards. There he found what he was looking for, and this voluble, kinetic, and often funny book recounts his experiences. Heโs cheeky about Sandhurst, describing it as โHogwarts with gunsโ and asserting that military knowledge and leadership were taught primarily through โMARCHING, IRONING, and SHOUTING,โ but he also acknowledges the programโs effectiveness. (He became the Royal Armyโs youngest captain.) His time in Iraq melded boredom and frustration because he and his fellow guards realized they โwerenโt going to have a fightโ in Baghdad; with time on their hands, Hennessey and his fellow junior guards formed the titular reading club. Reassigned to Afghanistan, however, he found his fights, which rivaled Korea and even WWII in intensity. The bookโs pace, never leisurely, accelerates in Afghanistan, as Hennessey vividly describes near-constant battle with Taliban fighters and confronts his reactions: exhaustion, fear, grief, fellowship, confusion, and what he calls the โraptureโ of war. All wars generate fine books. This may be one of the best to come out of the war in Afghanistan. --Thomas Gaughan