Religion as Anthropomorphism: A New Theory that Invites Definitional and Epistemic Scrutiny
✍ Scribed by Edward A. Yonan
- Publisher
- Elsevier Science
- Year
- 1995
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 52 KB
- Volume
- 25
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0048-721X
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
✦ Synopsis
This essay will focus briefly on (1) a definitional and (2) an epistemic analysis of Stewart Guthrie's cultural-anthropological theory of anthropomorphism in his book Faces in the Clouds. In Part I of the essay, I will examine specific definitional claims about religion that Guthrie advances in chapter 1 ('The Need for a Theory') and chapter 3 ('The Origin of Anthropomorphism'). In Part II, crucial statements in chapter 6 ('Anthropomorphism in Philosophy and Science') and chapter 7 ('Religion as Anthropomorphism') raise questions about Guthrie's epistemic assumptions that in philosophy and science the objects referred to as anthropomorphic have critically been known to be errors and have been wisely set aside in the margins of those enterprises, whereas the objects referred to as anthropomorphic in religion have always been at the centre of religion. Guthrie employs five theoretical criteria (of observability, simplicity, generality, fallibility, and probability) to explain why religion always anthropomorphizes. The essay concludes with a formal question about the epistemic status of Guthrie's observability and universality criteria.