Occam's Razor in sensorimotor learning
β Scribed by Genewein, T.; Braun, D. A.
- Book ID
- 121529628
- Publisher
- The Royal Society
- Year
- 2014
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 714 KB
- Volume
- 281
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0080-4649
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
β¦ Synopsis
A large number of recent studies suggest that the sensorimotor system uses probabilistic models to predict its environment and makes inferences about unobserved variables in line with Bayesian statistics. One of the important features of Bayesian statistics is Occam's Razorβan inbuilt preference for simpler models when comparing competing models that explain some observed data equally well. Here, we test directly for Occam's Razor in sensorimotor control. We designed a sensorimotor task in which participants had to draw lines through clouds of noisy samples of an unobserved curve generated by one of two possible probabilistic modelsβa simple model with a large length scale, leading to smooth curves, and a complex model with a short length scale, leading to more wiggly curves. In training trials, participants were informed about the model that generated the stimulus so that they could learn the statistics of each model. In probe trials, participants were then exposed to ambiguous stimuli. In probe trials where the ambiguous stimulus could be fitted equally well by both models, we found that participants showed a clear preference for the simpler model. Moreover, we found that participantsβ choice behaviour was quantitatively consistent with Bayesian Occam's Razor. We also show that participantsβ drawn trajectories were similar to samples from the Bayesian predictive distribution over trajectories and significantly different from two non-probabilistic heuristics. In two control experiments, we show that the preference of the simpler model cannot be simply explained by a difference in physical effort or by a preference for curve smoothness. Our results suggest that Occam's Razor is a general behavioural principle already present during sensorimotor processing.
π SIMILAR VOLUMES
The body was positioned so that the train neatly obliterated its head and hands. Dressed in a homeless man's clothes with empty pockets, it might easily be passed-off as an unfortunate John Doe. And yet Joe Gunther has a knack for knowing when things don't quite add up, and the math in this case is
The body was positioned so that the train neatly obliterated its head and hands. Dressed in a homeless man's clothes with empty pockets, it might easily be passed-off as an unfortunate John Doe. And yet⦠Joe Gunther has a knack for knowing when things don't quite add up, and the math in this case is