Humanizing education: Subjective and objective aspects

✍ Scribed by Kenneth A. Strike

• Book ID: 104743570
• Publisher: Springer
• Year: 1991
• Tongue: English
• Weight: 1011 KB
• Volume: 11
• Category: Article
• ISSN: 0039-3746
• DOI: 10.1007/bf00368401

✦ Synopsis

I propose that there are four standards to be met if a given educational enterprise is to be considered humane: (1) the practice to be mastered must be socially justified; (2) the disciplines pursued to master the practice must be appropriate to the practice; (3) the practice must be owned by the learner; and (4) this ownership must itself meet certain ethical requirements. The paper emphasizes the problem of ownership. It argues for a view of ownership that is "communitarian." This view sees ownership as a function of identification or membership. People become committed to certain educational ends in virtue of the fact that they see themselves as members of a group and the ends as the ends of the group. It is central to this view that ownership of ends does not require full understanding or rational appraisal of such ends. I argue that a rational appraisal of ends is difficult when a novice seeks to appraise the ends of some practice both because the ends of the practice are internal to it in a way that makes grasping such ends difficult prior to mastery of the practice and because initiation into the practice will change the individual's standards of appraisal.