𝔖 Scriptorium
✦   LIBER   ✦

📁

Faculty Peer Group Mentoring in Higher Education: Developing Collegiality through Organised Supportive Collaboration (Higher Education Dynamics, 61)

✍ Scribed by Thomas de Lange (editor), Line Wittek (editor)


Publisher
Springer
Year
2023
Tongue
English
Leaves
222
Category
Library

⬇  Acquire This Volume

No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.

✦ Synopsis



This book addresses how peer group mentoring in higher education can contribute to the development of supportive and collaborative working environments for faculty staff. It draws on an extensive empirical study examining how group based peer-mentoring methods are implemented and experimented within four different academic communities at one university, and documents how these environments and their participants experience peer group mentoring as a collaborative measure in the development of teaching and supervision practices. The book presents a literature review of research on peer group mentoring in higher education and provides the conceptual grounding for the book, placing peer group mentoring within the field of faculty development.

The work presents analyses of the enactment of peer group mentoring in different environments and of faculty peers’ engagement and collaboration with colleagues within the same teacher community, across teaching and supervision communities and across institutional boundaries. It also discusses the significance of trust in these peer group mentoring settings, summarises the implications of the reported findings and addresses the role this peer based approach might play in developing supportive collegiality in higher education as a working environment.

✦ Table of Contents


Preface
Introductory Comment
References
Acknowledgement Including Information of Funding
Contents
Chapter 1: Peer Group Mentoring Among Faculty Staff in Higher Education
Introduction
Peer Group Mentoring as Collegial Faculty Development
Research on Peer Group Mentoring in Relation to Pedagogical Practices
Contextual Factors: How and Why Peer Group Mentoring Is Initiated and Implemented
Relational Factors: How Participants Collaborate, Interact and Develop Trust
Individual Factors: Significance of Pedagogical Experience and Preconceptions
Studying Faculty Peer Group Mentoring in Four Specific University Settings
The Chapters of the Book
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 2: Feedback in the Context of Peer Group Mentoring: A Theoretical Perspective
Introduction
What Establishes Feedback Dialogues?
Feedback as Interaction
Relational Trust
Learning Potentialities
Shared Understanding of the Purposes of and Actions in Peer Group Mentoring
Dialogues Between Colleagues as Contextual and Relational Acts
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 3: Peer Group Mentoring: Exploring the Interplay with Institutional Practices
Peer Group Mentoring in Context: Development Processes in a Complex Landscape
The Interplay of Peer Group Mentoring with Institutional Practices: Theoretical Perspectives
Empirical Context and Analytical Approach
Institutional Practices in the Planning of the Peer Group Mentoring Process
Institutional Practices as an Object of Change
Institutional Practices as Factors Informing Peer Group Mentoring
Institutional Practices: Looking Back at the Intervention
Development Work and Institutional Practices: Interplay and Counterplay
Pedagogical Practices
Organisational Practices
Epistemic Practices
Governance Practices
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 4: Interactional Dynamics in Observation-Based Peer Group Mentoring
Introduction
Challenges Associated with the Programme of Professional Study in Theology
The Peer Group Mentoring Process and Analytical Approaches
OPGM Founded on Dialogical Interaction
Methodological Approach
Two Mentoring Processes
Case 1: Tom’s Mentoring Process
Excerpt 4.1
Excerpt 4.2
Case 2: Sondre’s Mentoring Process
Excerpt 4.3
Excerpt 4.4
Excerpt 4.5
Excerpt 4.6
Discussion
Forms of Interaction and Potential for Learning
What Can We Learn?
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 5: Dialogue and Artefacts as Instruments in Peer Group Mentoring and Supervision of Problem-Based Learning in Higher Education
Introduction
Research Insights
Dialogue as an Instrument for Innovation in Supervision Practices
Textual Artefacts as Tools for Productive Dialogue
PBL as a Pedagogical Model and Group Dynamics in PBL
An Empirical Case: Peer Group Mentoring and PBL Supervision in a Pharmacy Programme
Peer Group Mentoring in the Pharmacy Education Programme: An Innovation in Two Parts
Subproject 1: Addressing Group Dynamics in PBL
Subproject 2: Observation-Based Peer Group Mentoring (OPGM) Meetings for Novice Supervisors
Knowledge Tools Used in PBL Group Meetings and in the Subprojects
Dataset and Analysis
Findings
Dialogue and Artefacts Mediating Discussion of Challenges and Solutions
Identifying PBL Supervision Challenges Through Dialogue
Artefact Is Transformed Through Dialogue
Dialogue as Instrument for Shared Exploration and Reflection
Reflection on the Role of Dialogue and Textual Artefacts in PBL Supervisory Practice
Artefacts as Tools for Supporting Group Dynamics in PBL Groups
Dialogue and Artefacts as a Strategy for Developing Supervisor Competence
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 6: Developing Research Supervision Capacity in Clinical Health Professions: Structured Peer Group Mentoring as Collegial Support in a Research School Context
Introduction
The Context
Perspectives on Academic Supervision
Developing a Peer Group Mentoring Model for the Research School
Materials and Methods
Results
The Types of PhD Supervision Issues That Were Raised During Problem-Based Peer Group Mentoring Sessions
Perceived Relevance and Shortcomings of Problem-Based Mentoring
Excerpt 6.1
Excerpt 6.2
Excerpt 6.3
Excerpt 6.4
Excerpt 6.5
Discussion
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 7: Problem-Based Peer Group Mentoring and Organisational Learning
Introduction
Background and Previous Research
Material
What Types of Structural Problems Were Revealed?
Supervisor Assignment Practice
Barriers to Communication Between Groups of Employees
New Employees from Other Academic Cultures
Views of the Model Compared with the Course as a Whole
Changes to Individual and Organisational Practice
Discussion
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 8: Problem-Based Peer Group Mentoring: A Tool for Faculty Development
Introduction
Context and Peer-Mentoring Model
Methods
Our Theoretical View: Mediated Action and ‘Interthinking’
Three Cases
Case 1: Genuine Interthinking
Analytical Comments: Example 1
Case 2: Lack of Attention
Analytical Comments: Example 2
Case 3: Resistance Towards the Model
Analytical Comments: Example 3
Discussion
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 9: Analysing the Emergence of Trust in Peer Group Mentoring
Introduction
Why Talk About Trust in Peer Group Mentoring?
Theoretical Perspectives on Trust
Trust in Peer Relations
Analysing Evolving Trust in Peer Group Mentoring: Two Models and Three Examples
Material
Example 1: Sequential Trust in Observation-Based Peer Group Mentoring (OPGM)
Example 2: Cumulative Trust in Problem-Based Peer Group Mentoring (PPGM)
Example 3: Disrupted Trust in Problem-Based Peer Group Mentoring (PPGM)
Why These Variations in Trust Development?
Discussion
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 10: Experiences from the PeTS Project: What Lessons Have We Learned, and How Should We Proceed?
Introduction
Peer Group Mentoring Models in PeTS: Principles and Practical Implementation
Discussing Peer Group Mentoring Outcomes Across Academic Boundaries
Moving from Teaching and Supervision as a Private Matter to Teaching as a Collegial Responsibility
Concluding Comments
References
Chapter 11: The Power of Collegiality in Developing Higher Education
The Private Nature of Teaching
Peer Group Mentoring and Collegiality
Teaching Cultures and Collegiality
Roads Ahead and Future Research
References
Chapter 12: Rebuilding Collegiality?
Introduction
Peer Group Mentoring, Collegiality and a Systematic Development Processes Framework
The Need to Raise Awareness of ‘Collegiality’
The Need to Decontextualise the Methodology
The Need to Expand the Area of Application
Final Reflections
References


📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES


Computer-Supported Collaborative Learnin
✍ Tim S. Roberts 📂 Library 📅 2004 🏛 Idea Group Publishing 🌐 English

Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning in Higher Education provides a resource for researchers and practitioners in the area of computer-supported collaborative learning (also known as CSCL); particularly those working within a tertiary education environment. It includes articles of relevance to

Computer-Supported Collaborative Learnin
✍ Tim S. Roberts 📂 Library 📅 2004 🏛 Idea Group Publishing 🌐 English

Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning in Higher Education provides a resource for researchers and practitioners in the area of computer-supported collaborative learning (also known as CSCL); particularly those working within a tertiary education environment. It includes articles of relevance to

Computer-Supported Collaborative Learnin
✍ Roberts T.S. 📂 Library 📅 2005 🌐 English

Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning in Higher Education offers a resource for researchers and practitioners in the area of computer-supported collaborative learning (also known as CSCL), particularly those working within a tertiary education environment. This publication includes discussions o

Best Practices for Mentoring in Online P
✍ Susan Ko, Olena Zhadko 📂 Library 📅 2022 🏛 Routledge 🌐 English

Best Practices for Mentoring in Online Programs is a straightforward guide to creating meaningful, lasting mentoring programs for faculty or students enrolled in fully or predominantly online programs. Faculty and student mentoring programs are proliferating in higher education, including peer mento