It's been several months since Nathan Ferland managed to win the heart of his true love, Amanda Tilley. He had to make a difficult choice to achieve it, but in the end it was well worth it. Now, Nathan feels on top of the world. After sending Hilbert Melendez--Amanda's former talent agent turned sexual offender--to jail, Amanda and Nathan can be happy together. The two spend the New Year holidays getting to better know each other.
With Valentine's Day approaching, Nathan prepares a special surprise for Amanda. He feels sure about his love for her. However, Nathan had no idea what being Amanda's boyfriend truly entailed. The prospect is harder than he thought it would be. As a gorgeous and relatively well-known model, Amanda gets lots of attention from the opposite sex almost anywhere she goes. The most notable is Christopher Holt, a guy with dubious intentions who has recently befriended Amanda. All of that is slowly getting on Nathan's nerves, even though he's trying his best to deal with it. To make matters worse, Rebecca Jenkins is secretly plotting to exact revenge on Amanda for what she did to Hilbert. In the wake of seemingly random incidents, Amanda is forced to recall her bodyguards. Since Hilbert is in jail, no one can guess who is after Amanda now.
Once Rebecca's machinations cause Amanda to begin doubting Nathan, things start to get worse. Soon, the least of Nathan's worries will be to lose Amanda's trust. If he can't discover who's behind it all, Nathan could lose the love of his life. He's about to learn that winning Amanda's heart was the easy part. Actually keeping it will be the real challenge.