This book provides a review of the multitude of conservation concepts, both from a scientific, philosophical, and social science perspective, asking how we want to shape our relationships with nature as humans, and providing guidance on which conservation approaches can help us to do this. Nature co
Conservation Concepts: Rethinking Human-Nature Relationships
✍ Scribed by Kurt Jax
- Publisher
- Routledge
- Year
- 2023
- Tongue
- English
- Leaves
- 271
- Category
- Library
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
✦ Synopsis
This book provides a review of the multitude of conservation concepts, both from a scientific, philosophical, and social science perspective, asking how we want to shape our relationships with nature as humans, and providing guidance on which conservation approaches can help us to do this. Nature conservation is a contested terrain and there is not only one idea about what constitutes conservation but many different ones, which sometimes are conflicting. Employing a conceptual and historical analysis, this book sorts and interprets the differing conservation concepts, with a special emphasis on narrative analysis as a means for describing human-nature relationships and for linking conservation science to practice and to society at large. Case studies illustrate the philosophical issues and help to analyse major controversies in conservation biology. While the main focus is on Western ideas of conservation, the book also touches upon non-Western, including indigenous, concepts. The approach taken in this book emphasises the often implicit strategic and societal dimensions of conservation concepts, including power relations. In finding a path through the multitude of concepts, the book showcases that it is necessary to maintain the plurality of approaches, in order to successfully address different situations and societal choices. Overall, this book highlights the very tension which conservation biology must withstand between science and society: between what is possible and what we want individually or as a society or even more what is desirable. Bringing some order into this multitude will support more efficient conservation and conservation biology. This book will be of great interest to students and scholars studying nature conservation from a variety of disciplines, including biology, ecology, anthropology, sociology, geography, and philosophy. It will also be of use to professionals wanting to gain an understanding of the broad spectrum of conservation concepts and approaches and when to apply them.
✦ Table of Contents
Cover
Half Title
Series Information
Title Page
Copyright Page
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
1 Introduction
1.1 Structure of the Book
References
2 Situating Conservation: Definitions, Origins, and Context
2.1 What Is Conservation?
2.2 Conservation: a Short Historical Overview
Origins in the 19th Century and Early 20th Century
Protection of Individual Organisms
Protection of (Particular Groups Of) Species
Protecting Remarkable Natural Features
Protecting Whole Landscapes
Early Conservation: Some Major Commonalities
Conservation After 1945
The Rise of International Conservation
The Increasing Influence of Science On Conservation
2.3 What Is Nature? A Preliminary But Necessary Note
2.4 Fuzzy Edges: Delimiting Conservation and Conservation-Related Research
Conservation as Practice: Related Fields
Preservation and Restoration: Parts of Conservation Or Distinct Fields?
Research Disciplines and Research Communities Linked to Nature Conservation
2.5 What Are Conservation Concepts?
2.6 Conservation Concepts and Their Societal Contexts
Conservation Biology as a Normative Science
Is There an Overarching “We” in Conservation?
2.7 Science and Conservation: an Ambiguous Relation
2.8 Case Study: the Debate About the “New Conservation”
Notes
References
3 Analysing Conservation Concepts
3.1 Different Criteria and Approaches for Analysing Conservation Concepts
Objects of Conservation
Values
Strategies
Tools
Case Study: the Oostvaardersplassen Experiment
3.2 Narratives as a Structuring Tool
What Are Narratives and How to Analyse Them?
Human–nature Relationships: an Overarching Structure
The Elements and Stages of the Masterfabula for Human–nature Relationships
(1) The World (“nature” and “Humans”) Coming Into Being
(2) Initial State: Humans Living In/from/with Nature
(3) Development/change of Human Interaction With Nature
(4) New State: Humans Living In/from/with Nature
(5) Crisis/disruption Perceived
(6) Anticipated/final State (Future)
(7) [Anticipated Course of How to Arrive at It]
A (semi-)fictitious Fabula of Human–nature Relationships in Conservation
3.3 Major Narratives in Conservation Concepts
Six and a Half Major Narratives of Human–nature Relationships in Conservation and Conservation Biology
Narrative: Humans Apart From Nature: Guarding Unspoilt Nature
Narrative: Caring for Other Living Beings (And Natural Features) Is Part of a Good Human Life
Narrative: Safeguarding Necessary and Useful Nature
Narrative: Being at Home in Nature
Narrative: Steering Nature in a Responsible Way
Narrative: Gardening Nature in Novel Ways
Narrative: Making Nature Whole Again
Comparing the Major Narratives
3.4 Conservation Concepts: Conceptual Clusters and a Matrix
Conceptual Clusters of Conservation Concepts
Cluster “Ecosystem Services”
Cluster “Biodiversity”
Cluster “Wilderness”
Cluster “Cultural Landscapes”
Cluster “Ecosystem Management”
Cluster “Novel Ecosystems”
Cluster “Restoration”
Supporting Concepts
Conservation Concepts Compared: Contrasts, Links, and a Matrix
Overall Legend for Tables 3.2–3.8
Notes
References
4 Western and Non-Western Ideas of Nature and Nature Conservation
4.1 What Is Nature? Philosophical and Anthropological Discourses
Different Dichotomies Characterising Nature in Western Philosophy
What Is Natural? Naturalness as a Descriptive and a Normative Concept
Why Human–nature Dichotomies Are Not Necessarily a Problem for Conservation
What Can It Mean to Overcome the Dualism Between Humans and Nature?
What Do the Natural Sciences Contribute to Conceptualising Nature? How Is Nature?
An Intermediate Conclusion
4.2 Case Study: “Does Nature Exist?” The Debate On Constructivism and Its Implications for Conservation
What Can It Mean to Speak of Nature as “Constructed”?
Does the Diversity of Concepts of Nature Promote Environmental Relativism?
Constructivism and the Human–nature Dualism
4.3 Ideas of Nature and Human–nature Relationships Beyond “Western” Thought
Caveats
Some Apparent Commonalities of Traditional and Indigenous Human–nature Relationships
An Indigenous World of Peoples/humans: Rainforest Dwellers in South America and Their Cosmology
Showing Respect: Native People of Northern North America and Northern Europe
Australia: Country as Narrative
Traditional Human–nature Relationships Revitalised? The Satoyama Initiative in Japan
4.4 Case Study: How Concepts of Nature Become Political: the Discourse On the IPBES Conceptual Framework
The IPBES Conceptual Framework
The Development of the IPBES Conceptual Framework
Buen Vivir and Western Human–nature Relationships
4.5 Narratives as a Tool to “Translate” Between “Western” and “non-Western” Ideas of Nature and Human–nature Relationships
Notes
References
5 Moving Forward: Which Conservation Concepts for Which Purposes?
5.1 Conservation Concepts: Progress Or Recurrence of Always the Same?
Much Recurrence But Also Some Important Trends
A Proliferation of Conservation Concepts: (When) Is It a Problem?
Arguments for a Pluralistic Approach
5.2 The Social and Economic Background of Implementing Conservation Goals
Power, Justice, and the Colonial Heritage of Conservation
Conservation, Economic Structures, and Radical Critiques
Is There a Common “We” in Conservation? No and Yes
5.3 Arriving at Good Relationships With Nature: Criteria and Requirements for Selecting Appropriate Conservation Concepts in Specific Settings
Different Purposes Using Conservation Concepts
The Relational Imperative: Embracing Relations as a Crucial Category for Conservation
Balancing the Needs and Demands of (Different Groups Of) Humans and Non-Human Species
Accounting for Biophysical and Social Constraints at Relevant Scales
Means and Ends: Conservation Concepts Should Not Be Strategic Only
Multiple Human–nature Relationships Should Be Accounted for
5.4 A Procedural Suggestion to Clarify Conservation Goals and to Tackle Conservation Conflicts
Notes
References
6 Conclusions and Outlook
Index
📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES
This introduction to the philosophy of the environment examines current debates on how we should think about the natural world and our place within it. The subject is examined from a determinedly analytic philosophical perspective, focusing on questions of value, but taking in attendant issues in ep
<p>8 SHORT REVIEW AND CONCLUSIONS OF THE INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM (“Conceptions and Methods of Nature Conservation in Europe”, Cluj-Napoca, September 16–19th, 2004) 1 1 2 Vasile CRISTEA , Dan GAFTA , John R. AKEROYD 1. “Babe -Bolyai” University, Department of Taxonomy and Ecology, Republicii str., 42
<p><P>Wildlife holds a special place in the human consciousness. It is a source of attraction and fear, material value and symbolic meaning, religious or spiritual significance, and it is a barometer of people’s concern for environmental sustainability. Why do humans care so much about wildlife? In
<p><span>Who Cares About Wildlife?</span><span> integrates social science theory in order to provide a conceptual structure for understanding and studying human interaction with wildlife. A thorough review of the current literature in conceptual areas, including norms, values, attitudes, emotions, w