𝔖 Bobbio Scriptorium
✦   LIBER   ✦

Aids, myth, and ethics

✍ Scribed by Per Sundström

Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Year
1991
Tongue
English
Weight
342 KB
Volume
12
Category
Article
ISSN
1573-1200

No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.

✦ Synopsis

The present paper is a commentary on an article by Larry Churchill. Churchill has argued that the negative attitudes and adverse behavior we commonly encounter in connection with (suspected) AIDS patients may be understood in terms of a dualistic 'myth' inspiring a 'ritual' avoidance of 'dirt', of 'dirt' as something that does not belong to a 'clean' world order. The deep-seated mythical character of attitudes and behavior here makes them less accessible to the kind of rational argument commonly employed in ethics. Churchill also proposes a remedy for the (morally outrageous) dualistic mythical-ritual behavior he has focused - a remedy that may be overly intellectualistic. Three further comments are made: on the metaphorical meaning of 'myth', on a reductionist tendency in Churchill's 'deep'-looking project, and on an ethically crucial ambiguity in the meaning of the other person's 'otherness'. These (mildly critical) comments do not, however, detract from a positive overall evaluation of Churchill's basic idea that we will understand more about adverse attitudes and behavior in connection with AIDS if we think in terms of 'myth', 'ritual', 'dirt', and 'cleanliness'.

📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES

Ethics, AIDS, and community responsibili
Ethics, AIDS, and community responsibility
✍ John Douard 📂 Article 📅 1990 🏛 Springer Netherlands 🌐 English ⚖ 912 KB

In the discussion of the responsibilities of society to the HIV infected and uninfected, a serious question seems to have been left out of the picture: To what extent are people who are not infected, have no special relationship to the infected and have no professional responsibilities for the care

The ethical imperative: Myth or reality?
The ethical imperative: Myth or reality?
✍ Constance R. Heiland; John P. Daniels; Hugh M. Shane; Jerry L. Wall 📂 Article 📅 1984 🏛 Springer 🌐 English ⚖ 832 KB
AIDS and ‘dirt’: Reflections on the ethi
AIDS and ‘dirt’: Reflections on the ethics of ritual cleanliness
✍ Larry R. Churchill 📂 Article 📅 1990 🏛 Springer Netherlands 🌐 English ⚖ 504 KB

AIDS and the responses and attitudes it evokes surpass the analytic abilities of standard bioethics. These responses and attitudes are explored in terms of literary and anthropological categories, such as dirt, disorder, pollution and ritual cleanliness. Implications for medical education are sugges