The writer thanks Zhao and Darwin for their thoughtful reply, shedding more light on the complexity of backscatter image processing. The writer takes this opportunity to comment on their reply and addresses some fundamental issues.
A reply to a discussion by D. Bonen of the paper “quantitative backscattered electron analysis of cement paste”
✍ Scribed by Hong Zhao; David Darwin
- Publisher
- Elsevier Science
- Year
- 1993
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 276 KB
- Volume
- 23
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0008-8846
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
✦ Synopsis
The authors appreciate Bonen's discussion. He has raised a number of useful points that should be addressed.
At the outset, it appears that Bonen has concluded that the preset gray levels used to identify phases within cement paste were selected based on "absolute" backscatter coefficients. This was not the procedure used in the study (1, 2), and the authors are pleased to correct this misunderstanding. The background information presented in the paper describing the application of the technique was aimed at establishing the theoretical justification for quantitative backscattered electron imaging. Knowledge of the backscatter coefficients is useful in establishing the relative intensity of the signals and determining if the signals produced by individual elements, or phases within cement paste, are sufficiently different to allow the materials to be distinguished from each other. If the contrast between individual phases is adequate, an imaging strategy can be developed to take advantage of that contrast. Thus, relative, not absolute, differences in gray level are used to identify specific phases within the imaged material. The techniques presented in the paper allow this to be done on a reproducible basis by allowing calibration of the instrumentation.
📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES
In our experiments, mortar samples were exposed to a CO2-enriched atmosphere (CO2-series) and to a CO 2 + SO2-enriched atmosphere (SO2-series). Because of the gas concentrations (0.7 vol.-% CO2; 0.06 vol.-% CO2) used, the dominant process consists in the reaction of CO 2 with the alkaline components
We thank J. Baron and M. Buil for their reference to our work and for the interesting comparison they have made with their experimental results.