A note on interval estimation of kappa in a series of 2×2 tables
✍ Scribed by Kung-Jong Lui; Colleen Kelly
- Publisher
- John Wiley and Sons
- Year
- 1999
- Tongue
- English
- Weight
- 100 KB
- Volume
- 18
- Category
- Article
- ISSN
- 0277-6715
No coin nor oath required. For personal study only.
✦ Synopsis
When there are confounders in reliability studies, failing to stratify data to account for these confounding e!ects may produce a misleading estimate of the interrater agreement. In this paper, we focus discussion on interval estimation of kappa for measuring agreement between two raters with strati"ed data. Using Monte Carlo simulation, we compare four asymptotic interval estimators of kappa for strati"ed data: estimator (1), a weighted average of the stratum-speci"c kappa estimates with weights equal to the inverse of the estimated asymptotic variances of these estimates; the two estimators, ( 2) and ( 3), with use of the logarithmic and the square root transformations, respectively, and a principle similar as used in estimator (1); estimator (4), a weighted average of the stratum-speci"c kappa estimates with weights equal to stratum sizes. We "nd that while the coverage probability of the "rst three interval estimators (1)}(3) can often be less than the desired con"dence level, the fourth interval estimator (4) consistently performs well in all the situations considered here. We further "nd that when the underlying is moderate (0)30) )0)50), we can substantially improve the performance of the "rst three estimators by using a point estimator recently proposed elsewhere for in estimation of weights. Because interval estimator (4) outperforms the other three estimators in a variety of situations, we recommend this estimator for general use.
📜 SIMILAR VOLUMES
For controlled comparative trials with matched pairs, in an attempt to improve the asymptotic interval estimator of the relative difference proposed elsewhere, I develop two asymptotic closed-form interval estimators with use of the logarithmic transformation and an idea used for deriving Fieller's
Allelic losses on chromosome arm 22q are frequently observed in human meningiomas and in carcinomas of the colon, ovary, and breast. Among 140 primary breast cancers we examined for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at 16 polymorphic loci on the long arm of chromosome 22, 56 (40%) showed LOH for at least